Copyright infringement not intended

Picture Courtesy:  DOWNTOEARTH

Context

The Journal Nature published research suggesting that the rapid expansion of protected areas worldwide gives a misleading picture of progress, as biodiversity continues to decline inside many designated protection sites.  

Highlights of the Study 

The Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework (GBF), adopted in 2022, set an ambitious goal known as the '30x30 target'—to conserve and manage 30% of the world’s land and oceans by 2030. 

Rapid designation of new Protected Areas meets targets but often fails to deliver genuine ecological protection, raising concerns about current conservation effectiveness.

Key Challenges Undermining Protected Area (PA) Effectiveness

The "Paper Parks" Phenomenon

Many PAs, particularly Marine Protected Areas (MPAs), lack the legal teeth or field presence to stop industrial activities. 

• Weak Regulations: Many MPAs allow commercial fishing, mining, or dredging within their borders. In some European Union MPAs, commercial fishing pressure is reported to be higher than in adjacent unprotected waters.
• Symbolic Status: Rapid expansion to meet international targets has often sacrificed management quality for total area coverage. 

Climate Change and Invasive Species

Warming climates destabilize ecosystems, favoring invasive species that outcompete native biodiversity. 

• Case Study: A Wildlife Institute of India (WII) study revealed that the invasive plant Lantana camara has infested 40% of India's tiger habitats.
• Ecological Impact: These thickets suppress native grasses, reducing the prey base (deer, gaur) for top predators like tigers and degrading forest health. 

Systemic Governance Failures

Management remains reactive rather than adaptive, failing to keep pace with dynamic environmental shifts. 

• Static Management: Many PAs use outdated plans that do not account for species shifting their ranges due to climate change.
• Resource Gaps: A persistent shortage of trained staff, modern monitoring technology, and surveillance capability leaves many areas unpatrolled. 

Conservation Financing Crisis

Achieving the global "30x30" target is hindered by a massive funding gap. 

• The Funding Shortfall: While current finance flows to nature-based solutions are roughly $200 billion annually, they must reach $542 billion by 2030 to meet climate and biodiversity goals. (Source: UNEP)
• Sector Imbalance: Governments supply 82–83% of total funding, with the private sector contributing only 17–18%. Annual investments in nature-negative activities (like fossil fuels and unsustainable agriculture) are over 30 times greater than conservation funding. (Source: Nature Report)

Concern about current funding models

• Short-Term & Project-Based: Unpredictable, project-based funding contrasts with the sustained, long-term financing PAs require for salaries, maintenance, and enforcement.
• Focus on Expansion: Most funding goes to creating new PAs instead of improving existing ones' management and enforcement.
• Uneven Distribution: Funding is heavily skewed; marine conservation consistently receives much less funding than terrestrial ecosystems, despite the oceans' vastness and criticality.
• Neglect of Indigenous Peoples & Local Communities (IPLCs): Despite managing areas with an estimated 80% of global biodiversity, IPLC receive under 1% of designated climate and conservation funding, ignoring their proven conservation effectiveness.

Way Forward 

Focus on Quality over Quantity

Ecological outcomes (e.g., stable species populations, ecosystem health) must measure success, not just the area designated as "protected." This requires clear, non-negotiable standards for protected area qualification.

Embrace Adaptive Management

PA management needs to be flexible, dynamic, and science-driven, with continuous monitoring and adaptive strategies for threats like climate change and invasive species.

Strengthen On-the-Ground Capacity

Effective conservation needs sustained funding for trained staff, strong enforcement, and rights-based engagement with local communities.

Reform Conservation Finance

Funding models must be redesigned to be long-term, predictable, and sufficient for recurrent management costs. Donors should better balance establishing new Protected Areas (PAs) with strengthening existing ones.

Empower Local Custodians (IPLCs)

Increase direct, flexible, and long-term funding for Indigenous Peoples and local communities. Recognizing their land rights and using their traditional knowledge is an equitable and effective conservation strategy.

Conclusion

Achieving the 30x30 target requires prioritizing the quality of protection, adaptive management, sustainable finance, and the empowerment of local communities to move beyond 'paper parks' and safeguard biodiversity. 

Source: DOWNTOEARTH