PAX SILICA EXPLAINED: WHY INDIA WAS LEFT OUT OF THE US-LED TECH ALLIANCE

The US-led “Pax Silica” alliance excludes India due to its early-stage semiconductor ecosystem, limited advanced manufacturing and trade frictions. Though a short-term setback, it echoes India’s MSP trajectory. Ongoing initiatives like the India Semiconductor Mission and National Critical Mineral Mission aim to build capacity for future inclusion.

Description

Copyright infringement not intended

Picture Courtesy:  INDIAN EXPRESS

Context

The United States launched "Pax Silica" with key partners (excluding India) to secure global supply chains for semiconductors, critical minerals, and AI.

What is Pax Silica?

It is a strategic initiative led by the United States aimed at creating a secure and resilient global supply chain for the semiconductor and Artificial Intelligence (AI) industries. 

It aims to build a "secure, prosperous, and innovation-driven silicon supply chain" among trusted allies.

It is designed to counter China's dominance in critical minerals and technology manufacturing. 

What are the Objectives of Pax Silica?

Reduce over Dependencies: To minimize reliance on any single country for essential materials and components, especially after China imposed restrictions on critical exports like rare earth magnets.  

  • China accounts for nearly 70% of the world's rare earths mining. It also controls roughly 90% of global rare earths processing. It also leads in refining nickel (68%), lithium (59%), and cobalt (73%). (Source: Oxfordenergy)

Secure AI Foundations: Protect the materials (like high-purity silicon) and capabilities (like advanced chip fabrication) that are fundamental to developing and deploying AI technologies.

Promote Allied Innovation: Ensure that aligned nations can collaboratively develop and scale transformative technologies without geopolitical disruptions.

Build Trusted Ecosystems: Create secure technology networks, including ICT systems, subsea fibre-optic cables, data centers, and foundational AI models.

Who are the Founding Members of Pax Silica?

The inaugural members of Pax Silica are nations with established, high-value roles in the global semiconductor supply chain. India was not included.

Founding Members

Key Contribution to Supply Chain

United States

Leads in chip design (IP), electronic design automation (EDA) software, and manufacturing equipment.

Japan

Dominates in specialized materials like photoresists and silicon wafers.

Republic of Korea

Global leader in memory chip (DRAM, NAND) fabrication and a major player in logic chip manufacturing.

Netherlands

Home to ASML, which holds a monopoly on essential Extreme Ultraviolet (EUV) lithography machines for advanced chipmaking.

United Kingdom

Strong in semiconductor IP and design, notably through companies like Arm Holdings.

Other Members

Singapore, Israel, UAE, and Australia, each contributing in areas like R&D, fabrication, investment, and raw materials.

Why India Was Not Included?

India's exclusion is not a reflection of its strategic importance but rather its current position within the high-tech manufacturing supply chain. Key reasons include:

  • Nascent Semiconductor Ecosystem: India excels in chip design but lags in commercial semiconductor fabrication (fabs) and advanced packaging, which are still developing.
  • Lack of High-Grade Processing: India holds quartz reserves, a critical raw material, but lacks the domestic capacity to process it into the high-purity silicon needed for semiconductor manufacturing.
  • Focus on Established Players: The initial group includes countries with established, significant comparative advantages in a specific semiconductor value chain segment.

Way Forward

India often joins alliances later. For example, India wasn't a founding member of the US-led Minerals Security Partnership (MSP) but joined in 2023, this indicates that as India's domestic capabilities develop, inclusion in frameworks like Pax Silica is highly probable.

 Source: INDIAN EXPRESS

PRACTICE QUESTION

Q. Critically analyze the factors contributing to India's exclusion from the inaugural 'Pax Silica' initiative. 150 words

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Pax Silica is a strategic initiative led by the United States with eight partner countries. Its core objective is to build a secure, stable, and innovation-driven global supply chain for semiconductors, critical minerals, and artificial intelligence (AI), thereby reducing dependence on countries like China.

India's exclusion is primarily due to three factors: its semiconductor manufacturing ecosystem is still in a nascent stage, it currently lacks the advanced technology and scale that the alliance focuses on, and unresolved frictions in the ongoing India-US trade deal negotiations.

The founding members are the United States, Japan, the Republic of Korea, Singapore, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, Israel, the United Arab Emirates, and Australia.

Free access to e-paper and WhatsApp updates

Let's Get In Touch!