IAS Gyan

Daily News Analysis

Impact of US Court judgement on IVF

18th April, 2024 Social Issues

Impact of US Court judgement on IVF

Disclaimer: Copyright infringement not intended.

IN NEWS

Alabama Supreme Court Ruling:

  • The Alabama Supreme Court decided that frozen embryos are like children.
  • This decision has big effects on how in-vitro fertilization (IVF) is done.
  • The ruling came from a case where three couples sued a fertility clinic.
  • This was because someone took some embryos from the clinic without permission.

Alabama's Wrongful Death of a Minor Act:

  • This law lets people take legal action if someone's actions lead to a child's death.
  • But it didn't say what a "child" is exactly.
  • The new ruling says this law also covers unborn children, even if they're not in a womb.

Impact on US Politics and Abortion Debates:

  • This ruling has restarted debates in the US about abortion.
  • It matches with the Republican party's view that life begins at conception, so they're against abortion.

Republican Stance and the IVF Paradox:

  • Republicans generally support IVF as a way for couples to have children.
  • But this ruling puts them in a tricky spot because it aligns with their pro-life view, which could affect how IVF is done.

Alabama's Legislative Response and Future Implications:

  • To address the ruling, Alabama made a new law to protect doctors and IVF clinics from legal issues.
  • This law shields them from lawsuits related to embryo damage or death during IVF.
  • However, it doesn't solve all the questions raised by the ruling, showing that IVF laws are still complex.

MUST READ ARTICLE: Assisted Reproductive Technology Regulations (ART), 2023: https://www.iasgyan.in/daily-current-affairs/assisted-reproductive-technology-regulations-art-2023

PRACTICE QUESTION

Q. Evaluate the Assisted Reproductive Technology Regulations (ART), 2023. Discuss its impact on the legal framework and ethical considerations regarding in-vitro fertilization (IVF) practices.

SOURCE: INDIAN EXPRESS