EVOLVING GLOBAL TRADE PACTS: CHALLENGES AND WAY FORWARD FOR INDIA

Copyright infringement not intended

Picture Courtesy:  THE HINDU

Context

India is adopting a dynamic trade strategy, finalized modern agreements with the UK, Oman, New Zealand, and the EU in 2025-26, which include new provisions on environment, labor, and digital trade.

Read all about: INDIA-EFTA TRADE AND ECONOMIC PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT (TEPA) l INDIA APPROACH IN TRADE AGREEMENT l INDIA AND GLOBAL AGREEMENTS l INDIA-EU FREE TRADE AGREEMENT l UK-INDIA FREE TRADE AGREEMENT l  INDIA-GCC FREE TRADE AGREEMENT

Evolution of Trade Agreements

Modern international trade agreements are shifting from tariff-focused "goods-only" Regional Trade Agreement (RTA) to comprehensive strategic partnerships that include digital trade, supply chain resilience, and environmental standards.

The Historical Arc of Global Trade Pacts

The nature of trade agreements has evolved through three distinct phases, moving from simple market access to deep, strategic integration.

Era	Primary Focus	Key Characteristics & Examples
Era 1: Post-WWII (GATT/Early WTO)	Reducing Border Barriers	Main goal was to lower visible trade barriers like tariffs (customs duties) and quotas (quantity limits). Agreements were shallow and focused primarily on trade in goods. Example: The General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT).
Era 2: Deep Integration (Late 1990s - 2010s)	Beyond-the-Border Integration	Included complex new areas like services, investment rules, and intellectual property rights (IPR). The WTO's TRIPS (Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights) agreement is a prime example. Sought to harmonize domestic regulations to facilitate deeper economic integration.
Era 3: The Current Pivot (Post-2020)	Sovereign Resilience & Values	Driven by the COVID-19 pandemic and geopolitical tensions. Prioritizes supply chain security, digital governance, and sustainability over pure cost-efficiency. Concepts like "Friend-shoring" (trading with trusted allies) have gained prominence.

Core Pillars of New-Age Trade Agreements

Digital Trade and AI Governance

As the global economy digitizes, rules governing data are becoming a central part of trade negotiations. Key areas include:

• Cross-Border Data Flows: Establishing rules for the seamless transfer of data between countries, which is vital for the tech industry.
• Data Localization: Addressing requirements by some countries that data be stored domestically. Agreements often seek to limit mandatory data localization.
• AI Ethics and Governance: Setting standards for the ethical use of Artificial Intelligence in trade and commerce.
• Example: The Digital Economy Partnership Agreement (DEPA) between Singapore, Chile, and New Zealand is a pioneering model for digital trade rules.

Sustainability and Labour Standards

Trade is increasingly being used as a tool to promote environmental and social goals. These "green clauses" include:

• Environmental Standards: Commitments to multilateral environmental agreements and sustainable practices.
• Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM): A mechanism, notably proposed by the EU, to tax carbon-intensive imports (like steel and aluminium) to prevent "carbon leakage." This poses a significant challenge for Indian exporters.
• Labour Rights: Provisions ensuring fair labour practices, worker safety, and the prohibition of forced labour, aligning trade with human rights.

Supply Chain Resilience

The pandemic exposed the vulnerabilities of hyper-efficient global supply chains. The focus has now shifted from:

• "Just-in-Time" to "Just-in-Case": Moving away from lean manufacturing models that rely on timely deliveries, towards building redundant and resilient supply networks that can withstand shocks.
• Diversification: Encouraging businesses to adopt a "China Plus One" strategy to reduce over-reliance on a single country for manufacturing and sourcing.
• Friend-shoring: Re-routing supply chains to countries that are geopolitical allies, prioritizing security over cost.

Integration of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs)

To make growth more inclusive, new agreements often include specific chapters dedicated to helping SMEs participate in global trade. This is achieved through:

• Simplified customs procedures.
• Improved access to information and global markets.
• Digital tools to connect small producers and rural entrepreneurs with international buyers.

India’s Trade Strategy in New Global Order

India’s trade strategy underwent a "proactive and strategic" re-orientation, transitioning from a historically protectionist stance to becoming a leader in global economic integration.  

Shift to "New-Age" Bilateralism 

India has moved away from massive regional blocs (like RCEP) in favour of deep, comprehensive bilateral agreements with developed economies. 

• The "Mother of All Deals" (India-EU FTA): Concluded in January 2026, this agreement unites a market of 2 billion people. It provides duty-free access for 93% of Indian exports (including textiles and IT) while slashing Indian tariffs on EU luxury cars (from 110% down to 10% over time) and wines.
• India-UK CETA: Signed in July 2025 and expected to be operational by April 2026, this pact grants zero-duty access to 99% of Indian goods. It includes a unique Double Contribution Convention, saving Indian firms over ₹4,000 crore in social security payments.
• India-US Interim Agreement: Framework established in February 2026 for reciprocal trade, aimed at promoting mutually beneficial market access following a period of tariff tensions. 

Trade as a Geopolitical Tool

Trade agreements are no longer just about economics; they are now instruments of Strategic Autonomy. 

• Friend-Shoring: India is positioning itself as the primary "China Plus One" destination. By joining initiatives like the Pax Silica Coalition (2026) and signing the India-EFTA TEPA, India is securing critical mineral supplies and semiconductor value chains.
• Investment-Linked Pacts: Newer agreements include binding investment pledges. The EFTA deal (effective October 2025) includes a commitment of $100 billion in FDI and the creation of 1 million jobs over 15 years. 

Domestic Enablers & Sectoral Focus

To support the global outreach, the government has launched several domestic "force multipliers":

• Trade Connect ePlatform: A real-time digital portal launched to help MSMEs navigate FTA concessions and rules of origin.
• Tariff Rationalisation: The 2026 Union Budget simplified customs by removing outdated rates and exempting duties on inputs for high-growth sectors like EV manufacturing and seafood processing.
• Service Mobility: Unlike older deals, 2026 agreements prioritise the "Mode 4" supply of services, ensuring easier visas and professional mobility for Indian IT, healthcare, and financial experts. 

What are the Challenges for India in the New Global Order?

India's "New-Age" FTAs are hampered by complex regulatory barriers and domestic structural issues, preventing their full utilization.

"Green Protectionism" & Non-Tariff Barriers (NTBs)

The primary external roadblock is the shift from high tariffs to complex environmental and social regulations.

Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM): This EU "carbon tax" could impose an additional 20–35% duty on Indian exports like steel, aluminium, and cement. This effectively neutralises the 0% tariff gains won in the India-EU FTA.

Regulatory Onslaught: Rules like the EU Deforestation Regulation (EUDR) and Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence (CSDDD) require small Indian farmers and MSMEs to provide geotagging and traceability data, creating an unaffordable compliance burden.

Sanitary & Phytosanitary (SPS) Measures: Stringent safety standards in the US and EU lead to high rejection rates for Indian agri-products, often acting as "hidden protectionism". 

The "Import-Dependent Export" Trap

Value Addition Gap: In mobile phone manufacturing, domestic value addition is only 23%, meaning a spike in exports to the West automatically increases component imports from China.

Inverted Duty Structure: In sectors like electronics and chemicals, raw materials are often taxed higher than finished goods, making it cheaper to import final products than to manufacture them locally. 

Asymmetric Utilization & Widening Deficits

Low Utilization Rates: Indian exporters utilize only about 25% of available FTA benefits, compared to 70–80% in developed nations. This is largely due to complex Rules of Origin (RoO) and a lack of awareness among MSMEs.

Surging Imports: Agreements with ASEAN and the UAE have led to a widening trade deficit as imports grow faster than exports (e.g., the deficit with ASEAN expanded to $44 billion by 2023). 

Domestic Structural Bottlenecks

Logistics Inefficiency: India still relies on road transport for 71% of freight, leading to higher costs compared to competitors like China, who utilize more efficient rail networks.

MSME Credit Gap: A massive ₹30 lakh crore credit gap prevents small firms from upgrading technology to meet the stringent quality standards of Western markets.

Information Asymmetry: Many small-scale exporters remain unaware of the specific concessions and procedural requirements of new-age FTAs. 

Geopolitical & Strategic Frictions

Data Sovereignty: Disagreements over data localisation and cross-border data flows remain a sticking point in negotiations with the EU and US.

Strategic Autonomy vs Alignment: Pressures from the US to reduce Russian oil imports or align on specific sanctions create diplomatic irritants that can stall broader trade frameworks. 

Way Forward For India

The global trade paradigm has shifted from "Efficiency at any cost" to "Resilience at all costs." For India, trade is no longer a search for the cheapest supplier, but a tool to secure national interests, technological sovereignty, and economic stability. 

Transition from "Just-in-Time" to "Just-in-Case"

De-risking: India must reduce dependence on adversarial nations for critical inputs (like APIs for pharma or rare earth minerals for EVs).

Trusted Geography: Trade must be conducted through "Friend-shoring," prioritizing agreements with nations that share democratic values and security interests (e.g., the India-EU FTA and India-Australia ECTA) over those offering merely cheap goods. 

Trade as a Shield for "Sovereign AI"

Data Sovereignty: India must enforce clauses in trade deals that protect its right to store and process data locally. This ensures that AI models serving rural India (like BharatGen) are trained on indigenous data, preventing "data colonization".

Securing the "Brains": India needs to leverage coalitions like Pax Silica (2026) to secure semiconductor supply chains, ensuring that its AI-driven agriculture and healthcare sectors are immune to external "chip blockades". 

Exporting "Digital Trust" (DPI)

India should use its trade policy to export its Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI)—such as UPI and Aadhaar—as a global standard. 

DPI as Soft Power: By helping other Global South nations adopt the "India Stack," India creates a "technological sphere of influence" that bypasses Western financial intermediaries and reduces transaction costs.

Interoperability: Trade agreements should push for the acceptance of Indian digital standards, allowing an Indian MSME to receive payments from a buyer in France or Singapore instantly and cheaply. 

"Deep" Manufacturing over Assembly

To achieve true autonomy, India must move up the value chain.

Component Independence: The focus of schemes like PLI (Production Linked Incentive) must shift from final assembly (e.g., putting phones together) to manufacturing the core components (e.g., display screens, sensors) domestically. This reduces the "import intensity" of exports.

Critical Minerals: India must secure assets abroad (e.g., Lithium mines in South America/Africa) to ensure it controls the raw materials needed for its Green Energy transition. 

Strengthening Trade for Climate Leadership

Green Autonomy: India must invest in Green Hydrogen and renewable technology to ensure its exports can bypass Western "Carbon Taxes" (like the EU's CBAM).

Energy Independence: Trade policy should facilitate the acquisition of technology that accelerates India's transition away from imported oil, reducing the rupee's vulnerability to global price shocks.  

Conclusion

India must use trade to build such deep domestic capabilities and global digital linkages that it becomes a rule-maker in the global economy, rather than just a price-taker.

Source: THE HINDU

PRACTICE QUESTION Q. "Mechanisms like the EU’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) represent a new form of 'Green Protectionism' that could neutralise the gains of India’s recent trade pacts." Analyze. 250 words