IAS Gyan

Daily News Analysis

Glimmer of hope: On India-China five-point consensus

12th September, 2020 Editorial

Context:  India and China have taken the first step to begin real disengagement at the border


  • The “five-point consensus” reached by the Foreign Ministers of India and China in Moscow on provides a glimmer of hope of a diplomatic solution, while thousands of troops from both countries remain deployed along the border.

Only a glimmer

  • Each point, outlined in a joint statement, has been affirmed previously by the two neighbours, both in past boundary agreements and in talks held since June that have failed to de-escalate tensions.
  • The LAC remains tense, facing its worst crisis since 1962.
  • Both sides have agreed to take guidance from previous understandings, including on “not allowing differences to become disputes”, a formulation of 2017 that has not lived up to its promise.
  • They agreed the current situation suits neither side, troops should quickly disengage, maintain proper distance, and ease tensions.
  • Both sides said they would abide by all existing agreements, continue dialogue, and expedite work on finding confidence building measures to maintain peace.
  • At the same time, stark differences remain, including on the key question of whether both sides will return to the status quo ante prior to China’s transgressions.

Key issues

  • India stressed that peace on the boundary was essential for ties, and that recent incidents had impacted the broader relationship.
  • The Chinese on the other hand, sought to emphasise the importance of “moving the relationship in the right direction” and to put the border “in a proper context”.
  • China also quoted India believed China’s policy toward India had not changed and that it did not consider relations to be dependent on the settlement of the boundary question.
  • India’s stand have emphasised border peace as a prerequisite to taking forward the broader relationship.
  • China’s official news agency issued a commentary placing the onus entirely on India to defuse tensions, accusing India of “reckless provocations”, telling India “to learn from history”, and reiterating that China “will not lose an inch of territory”.
  • It is welcome that India and China have finally found something to agree on. The continuing rounds of talks should be aimed sincerely at disengagement, and not at presenting a veneer of diplomatic engagement even while China strengthens its hold along the LAC. India will need to verify before it can trust each of China’s steps from now on.

Reference: https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/editorial/glimmer-of-hope-the-hindu-editorial-on-india-china-five-point-consensus/article32584454.ece?homepage=true