Copyright infringement not intended
Picture Courtesy: newindianexpress
Context
A recent explosion in an illegal rat-hole coal mine in Meghalaya, which killed at least 27 workers, highlights the urgent necessity to stop this dangerous illegal mining.
Rat-hole mining is a primitive, manual method of extracting coal through narrow tunnels; only 3 to 4 feet high.
It is a common practice in the hilly terrain of Meghalaya, where coal occurs in very thin seams (less than 2 metres).
Core Characteristics
Technique: Miners—sometimes including children due to their small size—crawl into horizontal or vertical shafts to manually extract coal using basic tools like pickaxes, shovels, and baskets.
Main Types:
Legal Status: The National Green Tribunal (NGT) banned the practice in 2014, citing it as "unscientific and illegal". This ban was later upheld by the Supreme Court.
Geological Factors: Meghalaya’s coal seams are very thin, often described as "ribbon seams," making large-scale, open-cast mining economically unviable.
Socio-Legal Complexity (Sixth Schedule): Under the 6th Schedule, tribal communities in Meghalaya have land and resource ownership, which has historically been used to justify mining without adhering to national laws.
Supreme Court's Clarification (2019): In State of Meghalaya vs All Dimasa Students Union (2019), the Court affirmed tribal land ownership rights but mandated that all mining must adhere to central laws, like the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957, and environmental regulations.
|
Crisis Type |
Details |
Evidence / Example |
|
Ecological Degradation |
Acid Mine Drainage (AMD): Meghalaya's coal has a high sulfur content. When exposed to water and air, it forms sulfuric acid, poisoning water bodies. River Pollution: Acidic runoff contaminates rivers, destroying aquatic life and making the water unusable. |
The Kopili River has been identified by the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) as one of the most polluted rivers in the North-East due to AMD. |
|
Humanitarian Crisis |
Death Traps: The mines lack ventilation, structural support, and escape routes. They are prone to flooding and collapse. Child Labour: Narrow tunnels encourage the use of child labour, violating the Child and Adolescent Labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Act, 1986. |
The Ksan Tragedy (2018) saw 15 miners trapped and killed in a flooded mine. Recently, a blast in an illegal mine in February 2026 killed over 27 workers. |
|
Governance Failure |
Revenue Loss: State loses revenue from royalties and taxes due to the illegal nature of the operations. Official Complicity: Reports indicate a nexus between the "coal mafia," politicians, and local administration that allows illegal mining to continue. |
The Justice B.P. Katakey Committee, appointed by the Meghalaya High Court, highlighted large scale illegal mining, weak enforcement, and the administration's "dereliction of duty". |
Lack of Livelihood Alternatives
Mining is a primary source of income in the East Jaintia Hills. The ban lacked a robust "Just Transition" plan, forcing many into illegal mining out of economic necessity.
Regulatory Loopholes
Miners often exploit permissions to transport "already extracted coal" (legacy stock) as a cover for freshly and illegally mined coal.
Weak State Enforcement
The Meghalaya High Court criticized the state's "distressing" and "woefully inadequate" efforts to curb illegal mining, noting that operations continue in open defiance of court orders.
Technological Intervention
Surveillance: Utilize the North Eastern Space Applications Centre (NESAC) for satellite and drone-based monitoring to detect illegal mining activities and transport in real-time.
Supply Chain Digitization: Implement GPS-based vehicle tracking and digital logs for coal transport to prevent the laundering of illegally extracted minerals.
Policy & Regulatory Reforms
Transition to Scientific Mining: Meghalaya has started issuing scientific mining permissions. These operations must be expedited and strictly follow the Mine Act, 1952, regarding ventilation, safety gear, and support structures.
Cooperative Mining Model: Encourage local landowners to form cooperatives to pool their land, making it viable for semi-mechanized, safer mining operations under the supervision of entities like Coal India Limited (CIL).
Ecological Restoration
Utilize DMF Funds: Funds collected under the District Mineral Foundation (DMF) trust must be used transparently for the restoration of polluted rivers and the reclamation of abandoned mines.
Enforce Polluter Pays Principle: By seizing the assets of those involved in illegal mining to finance environmental remediation efforts.
A "Just Transition" Plan
Economic Diversification: Promote and invest in alternative livelihoods such as eco-tourism, food processing, and horticulture (e.g., Meghalaya’s famed Lakadong Turmeric).
Skill Development: Use schemes like the Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Vikas Yojana (PMKVY) to train the youth in alternative sectors, reducing their dependency on hazardous mining.
Learn Lessons from Global Best Practices in Small-Scale Mining
India should formalize and improve the safety of small-scale mining by adopting international regulatory models, rather than imposing an ineffective blanket ban.
|
Country |
Model |
Key Features |
|
Philippines |
Minahang Bayan ("People's Mining Areas") |
Specific, government-regulated zones legalize and control small-scale mining to ensure safety, environmental protection, and tax compliance, keeping the trade transparent. |
|
Peru |
Formalization Process |
Implemented a comprehensive registry for informal miners, offering them technical assistance, training in safety protocols, and access to legal markets in exchange for formalization and compliance. |
Conclusion
Meghalaya's mining tragedies stem from prioritizing economic interests over human safety and environmental laws, requiring a shift from failed prohibition to regulated scientific mining, accountability, and investment in sustainable local alternatives.
Source: THE HINDU
|
PRACTICE QUESTION Q. Economic interest cannot take precedence over human safety and environmental sustenance." Discuss this statement in the context of rat-hole mining disasters in India. 150 Words |
Rat-hole mining is a primitive and hazardous method of coal extraction prevalent in Meghalaya. It involves digging very narrow horizontal tunnels (3-4 feet high) into hill slopes to reach thin coal seams. The tunnels are so small that miners, often children, must crawl inside to extract coal.
The National Green Tribunal (NGT) banned it in 2014 due to its unscientific nature, extreme safety hazards (lack of ventilation and pillars), and severe environmental damage, including water pollution and loss of biodiversity.
It continues due to a lack of alternative livelihood options for the local population, the economic unviability of large-scale open-cast mining for thin coal seams, and regulatory failures often attributed to a nexus between the administration and illegal miners.
© 2026 iasgyan. All right reserved