Copyright infringement not intended
Picture Courtesy: THE HINDU
Context
In a complex multipolar world, India follows strategic autonomy by balancing relations with the US, China, and Russia while navigating challenges from US tariffs.
What is Strategic Autonomy?
Strategic autonomy means India's ability to make independent decisions in foreign policy and defense without external pressures or alliance obligations.
It prioritizes flexibility, allowing India to engage with multiple powers—U.S., China, Russia—on its own terms.
It is rooted in colonial history and Non-Aligned Movement (NAM), evolved into “multi-alignment” in today’s multipolar world.
External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar sums it up: ““This is a time for us to engage America, manage China, cultivate Europe, reassure Russia, bring Japan into play, draw neighbours in, extend the neighbourhood and expand traditional constituencies of support.””
Historical Roots & Evolution
Colonial Experience
- Centuries of domination sowed a strong determination in independent India to never allow external powers to dictate its global role.
- India's foreign policy is rooted in its freedom struggle ideals, emphasizing sovereignty, self-reliance, and dignity.
Non-Aligned Movement (NAM)
- Under Jawaharlal Nehru, NAM formalized this autonomy during the Cold War, allowing India to balance pressures from both the US and the Soviet Union without aligning with either bloc.
Post-1991 Shift
- With globalization and the emergence of multipolarity, India evolved towards a "multi-alignment" strategy, pragmatically engaging with all major powers while preserving its independence.
Drivers of India's Strategic Autonomy
Geopolitical Risks
- Borders with nuclear-armed China and Pakistan demand independent security options. India builds border infrastructure and indigenous weapons to deter threats without relying on one ally.
Resource Dependence
- India imports 85% of its oil and much defense tech. Diversifying suppliers—like Russian oil at discounted rates—prevents economic pressure.
Rising Power Ambitions
- India aims for a $5 trillion economy, positioning itself as a Global South leader.
- Autonomy allows India to amplify voices in G20 and BRICS without Western dominance.
Global Shifts
- Decline of US unipolarity, the rise of China, and the fragmentation of traditional alliances (eg. USA-EU) create more space for India.
Emerging Threats
- Cyber attacks and climate crises require cross-bloc cooperation with multiple nations.
How have recent actions by the Trump administration impacted US-India relations?
Imposition of Tariffs
- USA imposed 50% tariffs on Indian imports, charging New Delhi of "war profiteering" by purchasing discounted Russian oil. These tariffs are seen as an "economic war" and threaten Indian exports, making them uncompetitive.
Diplomatic Humiliation
- Trump's remarks about "losing India and Russia to deepest, darkest, China" and his claim for brokering a peace deal between India and Pakistan in May were viewed as "humiliating" by India.
Questioning India's Reliability
- Trump's expressions of disappointment over India's continued purchase of Russian oil, created uncertainty about the consistency and reliability of the US as a partner.
What is the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) and why is it important to India?
SCO is a permanent intergovernmental international organization comprising China, Kyrgyzstan, Russia, Tajikistan, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Pakistan, India, Iran, and Belarus.
Counter-terrorism and Connectivity
- SCO aligns with India's key objectives of counter-terrorism and enhancing connectivity across the Eurasian region.
- India seeks access to intelligence and information from the SCO's Regional Anti-Terrorist Structure (RATS).
Engagement with Central Asian Countries
Closer Indian-Russian Cooperation
- Allows India to maintain its proximity to Moscow, which supported India historically.
Balancing Chinese Dominance
- Russia views India's presence in the SCO as a counterweight to China's growing influence in Central Asia.
- SCO offers India a platform to engage with China while navigating its dominance.
Multilateralism
- SCO membership align with India's engagement in a multilateral global framework.
What are the challenges and opportunities for India in pursuing strategic autonomy?
Challenges
Economic Vulnerability
- Heavy dependence on imports for oil, defense equipment, and technology weakens India's bargaining power on the global stage.
China Factor
- Border clashes, an unsustainable trade deficit, and China's growing assertiveness compromise India's space and require a careful balancing act.
Alliance Pressures
- Balancing demands from various blocs, such as the U.S.-led Quad and the Russia/China-led BRICS-SCO, creates conflicting demands and risks.
Institutional Gaps
- Domestic political polarization, bureaucratic limitations, and capacity gaps hinder consistent foreign policy execution.
New Domains
- India lags in critical emerging technologies like cyber resilience, semiconductor supply chains, and space technology, which limit autonomy.
Uncertainty of Partnerships
- In a multipolar world, alliances are temporary, and commitments from powers (like US, China, Russia, or the EU) cannot be fully relied upon.
Opportunities
Bridge-Builder Role
- India can leverage its position to mediate between the Global South and developed countries, amplifying its diplomatic influence.
Technology Diplomacy
- Forming partnerships in areas like AI, quantum computing, and clean energy can reduce dependence and build resilience.
Defense Indigenization
- Initiatives like "Atmanirbhar Bharat" offer a chance to modernize defense capabilities with indigenous production, reducing reliance on foreign suppliers.
Soft Power
- Pluralistic democracy, large diaspora, and civilizational values enhance its credibility in international forums.
Voice of Global South
- Leadership in forums like the G20 and BRICS projects India as a legitimate representative of emerging economies.
Increased Flexibility
- Fragmentation of alliances and the decline of unipolarity create more space for India to drive and make independent choices.
To succeed, India must strengthen its economic, technological, and defense capacities, engage in balanced diplomacy, and blend principle with pragmatism.
Way Forward for India
Strengthen Economy
- Reduce trade deficits and oil imports by boosting manufacturing and renewable energy (target: 500 GW renewable capacity by 2030).
Modernize Defense
Balance Global Engagement
- Maintain ties with the U.S. and Indo-Pacific partners, retain historical links with Russia, and pragmatically manage relations with China. This represents Kautilya's principle of engaging all but aligning with none.
Lead Global South
- Advocate for reforms in international institutions (UN, WTO, IMF) and take initiatives on climate and development issues to shape the global agenda.
Adaptive Diplomacy
- Adopt pragmatic foreign policy, combining principles with realism to navigate fast-changing geopolitics and safeguard sovereignty.
Conclusion
Strategic autonomy ensures India to engage with major powers without losing sovereignty, balancing U.S. partnerships, Chinese rivalry, and Russian ties. By strengthening its economy, defense, and global voice, India can rise as a sovereign pole in global affairs.
Source: THE HINDU
|
PRACTICE QUESTION
Q. Economic interdependence is a critical tool in a multipolar world, but it can also compromise a nation's strategic autonomy. Critically analyze. 250 words
|
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Strategic autonomy refers to freedom to make sovereign choices in foreign policy and defense, prioritizing flexibility and independence without being tied down by alliance obligations.
India opposes China's Belt and Road Initiative because the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) section of the BRI passes through Indian territory illegally held by Pakistan.
The Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) is a Eurasian political, economic and international security organization of ten member states.
