Editorial Analysis 25 May

Daily Editorial Analysis

Editorial Analysis based on “Questions on press freedom” which was published in The Hindu Business Line.

Introduction:

• India’s recent ranking at 159th out of 180 countries in the World Press Freedom Index by Reporters Without Borders (RSF) is a warning.

Issues of Press Freedom in India

• Intimidation and Violence Against Journalists
  • The murder of Gauri Lankesh in 2017, a journalist known for her outspoken criticism of right-wing extremism, highlights the extreme dangers faced by journalists in India. Incidents like these create a climate of fear, discouraging investigative journalism and critical reporting.
• Censorship and Government Control
  • The blocking of the news websites and channels raises concerns about censorship and the suppression of dissenting voices.
• Legal and Regulatory Constraints
  • The use of sedition laws against journalists, such as the arrest of Siddique Kappan in 2020 under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA), illustrates how legal provisions can be used to stifle press freedom. These laws are often criticized for being vague and overly broad, allowing for their misuse against media personnel.
• Economic Pressures and Ownership Concentration
  • The acquisition of major media houses by large corporate entities with political affiliations can lead to biased reporting. The takeover of NDTV by the Adani Group in 2022 is seen as an example where corporate ownership could potentially influence editorial independence and content.
• Digital Surveillance and Internet Restrictions
  • The frequent internet shutdowns in regions like Jammu and Kashmir, especially the prolonged shutdown after the abrogation of Article 370 in 2019, severely impact the ability of journalists to report and access information. Surveillance and digital monitoring of journalists' activities also pose significant threats to their freedom and privacy.

Way Ahead for Press Freedom in India

• Strengthening Legal Protections for Journalists
  • Implementation of Robust Laws: Enact and enforce laws specifically designed to protect journalists from violence, harassment, and intimidation. Strengthening the legal framework can help ensure that journalists can operate without fear of retribution.
  • Establishing a Press Protection Act similar to the Shield Laws in the United States, which protect journalists from being forced to reveal confidential sources.
• Reforming Defamation and Sedition Laws
  • Review and Amend Legislation: Conduct a thorough review of defamation and sedition laws to prevent their misuse against journalists. Amend these laws to include clearer definitions and higher thresholds for prosecution.
  • Revising the sedition law (Section 124A of the Indian Penal Code) to ensure it cannot be used arbitrarily against media personnel for their reporting.
• Ensuring Media Pluralism and Independence
  • Promote Diverse Ownership: Encourage policies that prevent monopolies in media ownership and promote a diverse and independent media landscape. This can include regulations to limit cross-media ownership and foster competition.
  • Implementing policies similar to the UK's Broadcasting Act, which places restrictions on media ownership to ensure diversity and prevent concentration of media power.
• Enhancing Digital Freedom and Reducing Internet Shutdowns
  • Transparent Policies on Internet Shutdowns: Develop and enforce clear, transparent guidelines for the imposition of internet shutdowns, ensuring they are used only as a last resort and for the shortest duration necessary.
• Promoting Ethical Journalism and Self-Regulation
  • Encourage Journalistic Standards: Support the development and adherence to ethical standards within the journalism profession through training and self-regulation. Media organizations should adopt and uphold codes of conduct that promote accuracy, fairness, and impartiality.

Conclusion:

By addressing many areas of issues, India can create a more supportive environment for press freedom, ensuring that journalists can perform their essential role in a democracy without undue restrictions or threats